Kingdom Hearts by Tomoco Kanemaki, Tetsuya Nomura, Shiro Amano
Series Name: Kingdom Hearts (Light Novel)
Genres: Action, Adventure, Fantasy
Intended Age Group: 8+
Publisher: Yen On/Yen Press
Edition: Paperback
ISBN: 978-0-316-26019-0
Rating: 3/5
Amazon Barnes&Noble ThriftBooks
Description from the Book
On the Destiny Islands, three children – Sora, Riku, and Kairi – live out their peaceful, carefree lives while yearning for whatever lies beyond the great ocean. But one night, an unexpected disaster takes place, and the three are torn from each other and their island home. Meanwhile, at Disney Castle, Donald Duck and the other castle residents are in an uproar upon discovering King Mickey has suddenly gone missing. When fate brings them together, Sora, Donald, and Goofy set out on a grand Disney adventure to find their friends!
Personal & Info
This is a light novel adaptation of the popular game Kingdom Hearts. Adaptations are never one hundred percent accurate, so don’t expect this book to be. I’m always curious to read adaptations for things I like, because I want to see what’s different.
I’m not going to lie, it took me forever to get through this book, because I just was not in the mood for it. It was a slog to get halfway through, and then I pushed myself to finish the last hundred pages in one day.
Six color pictures of random events throughout the story are at the front of the book. All images in the book are illustrated by the same artist as the manga adaptation. Some of the black and white pictures look a little strange to me, like the one on page 62, because it looks like they tried to layer part of the picture, and it just looks weird where the parts overlap.
There are a few pages of character information after the table of contents. They cover some of the most significant characters, but they leave many out. Strangely, Donald, Goofy, Sora, Kairi, and Riku all have two entries. Based on the descriptions and art chosen, I get the feeling this novel is intended for people already familiar with the game.
Characters
Sora is the main character. He is exclusive to the Kingdom Hearts universe. Well, except for his Smash appearance. He’s basically your average joe with a heart of gold.
Donald and Goofy are popular Disney characters associated with Mickey Mouse. All three of them have been around for several decades, and they’re kind of the face of Disney, so it makes sense they would be main characters for this kind of story.
Mickey Mouse is a king in this universe, because he is the ever constant mascot of Disney. Donald is his court wizard, and Goofy is his head knight.
Riku and Kairi are also completely exclusive to the Kingdom Hearts universe. Riku is the cool edge lord loner type. Part of his relationship with Sora is Riku is always better than him at everything, but that changes a bit as the story progresses. Kairi is essentially the girl next door Sora and Riku are crushing on.
Various Disney and Final Fantasy characters make appearances throughout the series. The number of Final Fantasy characters is small, but the Disney quantity is high since almost all of the worlds are from Disney movies.
Story & Thoughts
Honestly, I think this book could have been at least twice as thick, or two or more volumes. The book is for ages eight and up, but I’ve read plenty of books for the same age group that were written much better than this.
My biggest complaint is there is not enough detail, for literally anything. If you don’t already know everything from the game, you likely won’t visualize anything correctly. Every time they describe one of the bosses, it doesn’t sound accurate. Whenever they describe a Heartless, it’s left mostly left to your imagination, even though there are canonical appearances for them. There is no picture index of Heartless to make up for the poor descriptions.
If you don’t already know all the appearing characters, you likely wouldn’t picture them accurately either. Their descriptions are overly simple, and the pacing makes them feel flat, because they aren’t around long enough to get to know them. Donald’s description doesn’t even tell you he is a duck. You can tell by the cover, and the fact he quacks, but that’s about it. There is zero mention of his unique way of talking, either. Everyone knows he has a weird voice, except those who grew up without any Disney television in their lives.
I really think that because this is a novelization of the game, it should go above and beyond in quality to try reaching audiences who don’t play the game or watch any Disney.
There are a significant amount of differences in this adaptation. Some of them are good changes to improve the flow of the story, like conversations on the gummi ship, because those feel like they add a little more depth as the group tries to figure things out. But, there are bad changes, too, and plenty that seem pointless.
Four whole levels are cut from the story. Olympus Colosseum, Atlantica, Halloween Town, and 100 Acre Wood. That means Ursula, Hades, and Oogie Boogie are cut from the group of villains. Even the manga adaptation doesn’t cut that many levels.
Some events, like boss fights and encounters, are seemingly pointlessly moved to other areas, basically in a different room than they are originally in. There are also boss fights cut completely, so some levels only have one. The entire book lacks summons. There are a total of none, so I’m curious how that will affect if Simba knows Sora in KH2.
It also seems like there are some plot threads that are quickly dropped, as if the game function of those plot points are inconvenient for the novel.
I know it probably seems like I’m ragging on the novel, but it’s actually not that bad. I like it well enough, and it does do some things well. Some of the dialogue looks like it is literally taken word for word, or at least as closely as possible, from the game. At a quick glance, the few pages of Ansem’s report that they read also look like they might be word for word, so points for accuracy on that.
The chapter, Fragments, on page 227, is a nice addition. It’s a scene where Riku finds himself in the realm behind the door, before Sora even finds the door. I don’t remember if that part is in the game, but I don’t think it is. Assuming it isn’t, I think that part is a nice little addition. There are a ton of little things, like transition parts, or what someone is thinking, that make improvements to the flow of the story.
There’s also progression to represent the level up growth of the game. It’s not specifically tracked, but the story includes parts where each of them learn abilities that you would equip in the game, or get boosts in power from something. The most obvious is Sora learning various new ways to use the keyblade, like throwing it.
I can’t help but laugh at some of the things they leave the same as the game. Anyone familiar with Kingdom Hearts knows the jokes about Donald never healing Sora. That’s still a running gag in this book. Donald never heals Sora. I’m not sure if he even knows a cure spell. Every heal in the game involves Goofy giving someone a potion.
If I had to choose which adaptation to read, between the novel or the manga, I’m actually not sure which I would choose. They’re both good in different ways, and they both cut things. Regarding just the light novel, though, I don’t recommend it for people unfamiliar with Kingdom Hearts. I think I feel the same as I did with the manga, where I think it’s a good book to use to scratch that itch if you’re in the mood for Kingdom Hearts but don’t want to play the game. As far as adaptations go, I say this one is mediocre, but not in a bad way.
