
Beautiful Darkness by Kami Garcia & Margaret Stohl
Series Name: The Caster Chronicles
Volume Number: 2
Genres: Contemporary, Fantasy, Magic, Paranormal Romance, Witches
Intended Age Group: YA
Publisher: Little, Brown/Hachette
Edition: Hardcover
ISBN: 978-0-316-07705-7
Rating: 3/5
Amazon Barnes&Noble ThriftBooks
Description from the Book
Ethan Wate used to think of Gatlin, the small Southern town he had always called home, as a place where nothing ever changed. Then he met mysterious newcomer Lena Duchannes, who revealed a secret world that had been hidden in plain sight all along. A Gatlin that harbored ancient secrets beneath its moss-covered oaks has marked Lena’s family of powerful Supernaturals for generations. A Gatlin where impossible, magical, life-altering events happen.
Sometimes life-ending.
Together Ethan and Lena can face anything Gatlin throws at them, but after suffering a tragic loss, Lena starts to pull away, keeping secrets that test their relationship. And now that Ethan’s eyes have been opened to the darker side of Gatlin, there’s no going back. Haunted by strange visions only he can see, Ethan is pulled deeper into his town’s tangled history and finds himself caught up in the dangerous network of underground passageways endlessly crisscrossing the South, where nothing is as it seems.
Personal & Info
It’s been about two years since I circled back around to this series. That’s way too long in my opinion, and I never intended it to take that long. I reread the first book before reading this one just to make sure everything would be fresh.
I don’t know what’s been going on with me lately, but I got stuck in a slump with this book. I don’t know if I just wasn’t in the mood for it or what. When I first started reading it, I got about halfway through, and then I couldn’t make myself read any more for a long time. After I finally got around to finishing it, I couldn’t make myself type the review. It’s been very frustrating.
There’s apparently some kind of inconsistent detail about Ethan and Link’s friendship. I thought I noticed it before, but I told myself I was imagining it. However, I looked back at my notes and review for the first book, and the detail is written different everywhere. Apparently every time the series mentions what school grade they were in when they first became friends due to the floor twinkie, it’s different. The right answer is probably kindergarten, but the spread is so vast. I swear they said sixth grade, third grade, second grade, and kindergarten. I plan to keep an eye out for this if it comes up again, because it’s really bugging me.
Characters
Ethan Lawson Wate is the main character. He’s six foot two, and his mother, Lila Jane Evers Wate, died in an accident about a year ago. Until he met Lena, he looked forward to the day he could leave boring Gatlin, South Carolina. Now he is realizing Gatlin has never been as boring and dull as he thought.
Amarie Treadeau, mostly known as Amma, is the grandmotherly housekeeper of the Wate household. She is barely five feet tall, smart, ornery, and is considered a seer, which is essentially a type of clairvoyant. To use her skills, she calls upon the powers of her ancestors.
Wesley Jefferson Lincoln, who goes by Link, is Ethan’s best friend. He has a car they refer to as the Beater, and he’s always up for helping Ethan, no matter how dangerous the ordeal.
Lena Duchannes (Du-Kane) is the main love interest. She is a powerful caster, yet to be claimed by good or evil.
Ridley Duchannes is Lena’s cousin. She is one year older, and they grew up together like sisters. Their relationship is a bit complicated, because Ridley was claimed by darkness on her sixteenth birthday.
Macon Melchizedek Ravenwood is Lena’s uncle.
Dr. Marian Ashcroft is the head librarian of both the regular library and the caster library. She is like an aunt to Ethan, because she was Lila’s best friend.
Olivia Durand is apprenticing under Marian for the summer. She is from Kings Langley, north of London.
John Breed, without spoiling too much, is a mysterious, powerful, edgy man, who contributes to the teen drama romance aspect of the story.
Sarafine, is Lena’s mother. She is a cataclyst, a powerful type of dark caster. Her specialty is manipulating fire.
Arelia is Macon’s mother. She’s a diviner.
Twyla is Lena’s great aunt. She is Arelia’s sister, and she lives in New Orleans. Her power is necromancy.
Several of Ethan and Lena’s other family members contribute to the story, but I don’t think they are worth listing here without spoilers.
Story & Thoughts
The book picks up a few days after Lena’s birthday, so there isn’t much of a time gap between volumes. I remember liking this book just fine on my first read a long time ago. My struggle to get through it this time might be adding some bias, but there are several things I don’t like about it now.
My general consensus for every volume on my first read was that all of the books drag a bit, so they feel slow. It still feels that way to me, but this one dragged even worse than I remember, because I had such a hard time picking it back up. At this point, I don’t really like Lena, and her drama actually feels detrimental to the story. The story is basically about her, but I can’t say I enjoy any of the parts that actually have her in it.
For the majority of the story, Lena is grieving. She has family around her, but her grief spirals to absolutely toxic and blatantly unhealthy levels. I can’t help wondering if her family is even doing anything to try to help her. It seems like they just leave her alone to process her own feelings, but that’s clearly the last thing she needs. Her behavior is the kind of teen melodrama that I don’t enjoy. I’m sure Lena’s behavior and attitude would make a lot more sense and probably be more entertaining from her perspective.
On the flip side, I love Ethan’s parts. The group of humans going on a dangerous magical adventure is the best part. Link gets way more screen time than he did before, and the love interest introduced to give Ethan internal conflict is actually likable. I swear Ethan has more chemistry with Liv than he does with Lena. Ethan and Lena are kind of boring together, but Ethan and Liv feel like they have some substance.
My original rating for this is a three. I’m keeping that as the final score, because I might not have been in the right headspace for it during a chunk of the reread. I feel like there’s about a fifty-fifty split of things that I like and dislike about it. Overall, it’s fine, but I really don’t like Lena anymore. I’m more of a Ridley fan. Ridley is way more interesting.